Talk Composites - The Forum for Advanced Composites
Back
Login
Register
Login
Register
Home
»
Advanced Composites Forum
»
Projects
»
Motorsport, Vehicle Design and Modification
»
Oil Catch Tank
Oil Catch Tank
Post Reply
Like
3
Prev
1
2
3
Jump To Page
Oil Catch Tank
View
Flat Ascending
Flat Descending
Threaded
Options
Subscribe to topic
Print This Topic
Goto Topics Forum
Author
Message
Hanaldo
Hanaldo
posted 11 Years Ago
ANSWER
Post Details
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 2.5K,
Visits: 28K
I would be interested where you get the 99% from I have done quite a bit of catch tank testing on race engines over the years and the exhaust/filter in the picture works well at separating the oil droplets from the air and retaining it within the tank. You have to be careful with baffles, fit them in the wrong place and you can build up quite a bit of back pressure within the tank restricting the air flow and therefor defeating the object really.
Warren
Is there a filter in the can? If so, it's not an empty system and will be doing more than the simple in-out empty cans. Out of interest,is the car this is going on street driven?
I agree that care needs to be taken with baffle placement, which is why functioning oil air separators need to be properly designed. Volume, baffles and flow. The idea is to slow the air down enough to allow the oil and water vapours to condense and separate from the air. An empty tank will not slow the air enough to allow this to happen. Obviously the air flow should not be slowed so much as to become a restriction, hence why volume is important. Trying to achieve flow and high vapour separation in a tank under 2L in volume is always going to be difficult.
Don't take my comments the wrong way, I don't mean to bad mouth your product. Obviously this all needs to be balanced with the customers needs, and if the car is street driven then it will always be a compromise as no recirculating catch can setup will be 100% efficient.
Reply
Like
1
wozza
wozza
posted 11 Years Ago
ANSWER
HOT
Post Details
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 688,
Visits: 5.4K
Hanaldo (01/03/2014)
I would be interested where you get the 99% from I have done quite a bit of catch tank testing on race engines over the years and the exhaust/filter in the picture works well at separating the oil droplets from the air and retaining it within the tank. You have to be careful with baffles, fit them in the wrong place and you can build up quite a bit of back pressure within the tank restricting the air flow and therefor defeating the object really.
Warren
Is there a filter in the can? If so, it's not an empty system and will be doing more than the simple in-out empty cans. Out of interest,is the car this is going on street driven?
I agree that care needs to be taken with baffle placement, which is why functioning oil air separators need to be properly designed. Volume, baffles and flow. The idea is to slow the air down enough to allow the oil and water vapours to condense and separate from the air. An empty tank will not slow the air enough to allow this to happen. Obviously the air flow should not be slowed so much as to become a restriction, hence why volume is important. Trying to achieve flow and high vapour separation in a tank under 2L in volume is always going to be difficult.
Don't take my comments the wrong way, I don't mean to bad mouth your product. Obviously this all needs to be balanced with the customers needs, and if the car is street driven then it will always be a compromise as no recirculating catch can setup will be 100% efficient.
Not offended hence the smiley face in my reply. As I see it when you post on a public forum you have to accept comments both good and bad
This particular tank is going on a Formula Student car being built by a university I have been helping. So no street use and only short run times. The tank is required as part of the regulations, all cars must have a catch tank capable of holding a minimum of 0.92L.
Warren
Carbon
Copies Ltd
Reply
Like
2
GO
Merge Selected
Merge into selected topic...
Merge into merge target...
Merge into a specific topic ID...
Open Merge
Post Reply
Like
3
Prev
1
2
3
Jump To Page
Similar Topics
Post Quoted Reply
Reading This Topic
Login
Login
Remember Me
Reset Password
Resend Validation Email
Login
Facebook
Google
Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search