Advanced guide - Working with pre-pregs


Author
Message
mawgan
mawgan
Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 12, Visits: 32
I am new here and have had a quick look through the forums and on the easy composites website/videos and I have yet to see any real advanced techniques shown (please correct me if I'm wrong and there is in fact advanced tutorials somewhere that state the techniques that I am referring to).

I have personally had over 10 years experience working with all aspects of advanced composites and the family run company that I own has been in the business for over 30 years. We have worked mostly in marine but have covered all aspects along the way from F1 through to aerospace.

I thought that I would list just a few things here and people can maybe carry this on and extend any knowledge/tips they may have learnt along the way.

To start with, no matter what composite project you are working on, it is all in the preparation, it is the most important thing. I.e, cutting materials correctly and all consumables ready to go before you even think about getting started. Working cleanly is also very important and something you learn working professionally within the industry. I will post some of my top tips of preparation and working cleanly later on this thread.

For now a couple of advanced pre-preg tips:

Spike rollers - I have not seen these listed anywhere on this forum or the main site, if you do not know what I refer to, it is basically a roller with spikes sticking out. It is important to spike roller each layer of pre-preg that you put down in the stack as this creates small holes within the otherwise solid resin structure for any air pockets to escape during debulking.

Debulking - As a general rule of thumb you should always debunk every 2 layers, along with the spike roller this gets rid of air pockets trapped in the stack and helps 'set' the pre-preg in place as you go.

Breather tows - A breather toe is simple a short tow of fibreglass placed around the edge of the laminate (in the area to be trimmed), you should place one tow roughly every 250-500mm for large panels/mouldings and smaller distances apply for smaller jobs. This is more important with infusion and Sprint system pre-pregs as it enables the air to escape more easily between layers but also applies to pre-preg as well if you want to do a professional job.

Pre-preg curing - I have had a quick look through the easy composites pre-preg offering and was surprised to find fairly basic information regarding the resin systems used and the cure process. Not anywhere mentioned is the recommended ramp rate for cure which is extremely important. As a general rule of thumb anywhere from 0.3C to 2C per minute is acceptable but this really depends on the application and should be specified by the manufacturer. Ramp rates allow the resin to flow correctly eliminating pin holes and voids and it allows the cured resins tg1 to stay ahead of the 'cure'.

Dwell times - A dwell is a temperature hold for a set period of time in order for the stack and mould to catch up with the rest of the cure, this all depends on the oven and should be analysed using oven test before curing any pre-preg. Once you have learnt your oven you can apply this to all future cures and can set an appropriate dwell time.

That concludes just a few things that I have noticed were never mentioned thus far. I am working on a very detailed pre-preg guide which will include many tips and goes into extreme detail in order to achieve results seen in the most advanced racing yachts/f1/aerospace applications. Please let me know if you are interested in this.

Please feel free to add any other advanced suggestions on working with pre-pregs and I will post more up when I have time.

Thanks and I hope this helps anyone interested.
wozza
wozza
Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 688, Visits: 5.4K
mawgan (17/08/2013)
I am new here and have had a quick look through the forums and on the easy composites website/videos and I have yet to see any real advanced techniques shown (please correct me if I'm wrong and there is in fact advanced tutorials somewhere that state the techniques that I am referring to).

I have personally had over 10 years experience working with all aspects of advanced composites and the family run company that I own has been in the business for over 30 years. We have worked mostly in marine but have covered all aspects along the way from F1 through to aerospace.

I thought that I would list just a few things here and people can maybe carry this on and extend any knowledge/tips they may have learnt along the way.

To start with, no matter what composite project you are working on, it is all in the preparation, it is the most important thing. I.e, cutting materials correctly and all consumables ready to go before you even think about getting started. Working cleanly is also very important and something you learn working professionally within the industry. I will post some of my top tips of preparation and working cleanly later on this thread.

For now a couple of advanced pre-preg tips:

Spike rollers - I have not seen these listed anywhere on this forum or the main site, if you do not know what I refer to, it is basically a roller with spikes sticking out. It is important to spike roller each layer of pre-preg that you put down in the stack as this creates small holes within the otherwise solid resin structure for any air pockets to escape during debulking.

Debulking - As a general rule of thumb you should always debunk every 2 layers, along with the spike roller this gets rid of air pockets trapped in the stack and helps 'set' the pre-preg in place as you go.

Breather tows - A breather toe is simple a short tow of fibreglass placed around the edge of the laminate (in the area to be trimmed), you should place one tow roughly every 250-500mm for large panels/mouldings and smaller distances apply for smaller jobs. This is more important with infusion and Sprint system pre-pregs as it enables the air to escape more easily between layers but also applies to pre-preg as well if you want to do a professional job.

Pre-preg curing - I have had a quick look through the easy composites pre-preg offering and was surprised to find fairly basic information regarding the resin systems used and the cure process. Not anywhere mentioned is the recommended ramp rate for cure which is extremely important. As a general rule of thumb anywhere from 0.3C to 2C per minute is acceptable but this really depends on the application and should be specified by the manufacturer. Ramp rates allow the resin to flow correctly eliminating pin holes and voids and it allows the cured resins tg1 to stay ahead of the 'cure'.

Dwell times - A dwell is a temperature hold for a set period of time in order for the stack and mould to catch up with the rest of the cure, this all depends on the oven and should be analysed using oven test before curing any pre-preg. Once you have learnt your oven you can apply this to all future cures and can set an appropriate dwell time.

That concludes just a few things that I have noticed were never mentioned thus far. I am working on a very detailed pre-preg guide which will include many tips and goes into extreme detail in order to achieve results seen in the most advanced racing yachts/f1/aerospace applications. Please let me know if you are interested in this.

Please feel free to add any other advanced suggestions on working with pre-pregs and I will post more up when I have time.

Thanks and I hope this helps anyone interested.




Welcome to the site. I think like me, some will value the advice you have given although the majority of people on this forum are making composites in their home workshops and EC provide an excellent service and product range for that market. Just my opinionSmile

Regards Warren 

Carbon Copies Ltd
mawgan
mawgan
Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 12, Visits: 32
Hi Warren

Many thanks for your response. I appreciate the service that is currently offered although the forum is called "Advanced Composites Forum" so a certain level of professionalism is required no matter what the objective. Even if you are making the simplest component from your own garage there is a very basic level of understanding that is required and I believe that the correct way to do something should be applied no mater how insignificant that may seem.

I see people all the time with what they refer to themselves as 'professional' who are completing composite projects with no knowledge of the basics, if you are doing anything you have to get it correct and I feel that shedding light on a few basics which people may know of but are not sure on how to apply this to there work will make all the difference in how there project will come out. I have seen a lot of posts here referring to "I get pinholes in my pre-preg", these are issue resulting from not one particular thing, but a combination of very small actions that can make a big difference in the end.

I hope to hear from you again.

Thanks.
wozza
wozza
Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 688, Visits: 5.4K
mawgan (17/08/2013)
Hi Warren

Many thanks for your response. I appreciate the service that is currently offered although the forum is called "Advanced Composites Forum" so a certain level of professionalism is required no matter what the objective. Even if you are making the simplest component from your own garage there is a very basic level of understanding that is required and I believe that the correct way to do something should be applied no mater how insignificant that may seem.

I see people all the time with what they refer to themselves as 'professional' who are completing composite projects with no knowledge of the basics, if you are doing anything you have to get it correct and I feel that shedding light on a few basics which people may know of but are not sure on how to apply this to there work will make all the difference in how there project will come out. I have seen a lot of posts here referring to "I get pinholes in my pre-preg", these are issue resulting from not one particular thing, but a combination of very small actions that can make a big difference in the end.

I hope to hear from you again.

Thanks.


Hi, again I agree with many of you comments in principle. Having spent over 25 years around composites starting in the Aircraft Industry I have seen Pre-Preg introduced and developed over the years to its current level. You talk about "Advanced Composites" yet you fail to mention Resin Infusion which is actually a newer and in my opinion more advanced process than Pre-Preg. You have total control over the amount of Resin in the part (unlike Pre-Preg which is dictated by the manufacturer) and for a fairly modest budget (compared to an autoclave) you can produce high quality pinhole free composite parts in a home workshop.

Warren

Carbon Copies Ltd
mawgan
mawgan
Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)Forum Guru (60 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 12, Visits: 32
Hi Warren

As I stated in my report, I am merely talking about pre-preg here that is why I posted this on the pre-preg board, I will write another one for resin infusion in due course. In my opinion, void free and pinhole free composites can be easily produced using a wet layup method (vacuum or no vacuum) its just about correct method.

I completely agree that resin infusion is a great way to manufacture components but each method has there advantages and disadvantages. Possibly the best method for void free composites is the SP GURIT Sprint system. It is a dry reinforcement with the resin contained within the centre of the cloth and a very light tack glue film on one side. This is basically infusion but with the resin already weighed perfectly for the cloth being used - resin infusion often produces a higher resin to cloth ratio than pre-pregs/sprint. You typically find that the void content is between 0%-0.5% with sprint.

Infusion also requires low viscosity resin systems which are often inadequate when compared to pre-preg resin systems but this really depends on what you are making, etc. But yes, infusion is a great way to go for easily making parts and is much safer/cleaner that wet layup but can have its problems when the mould/laminate gets a bit complicated etc.

Many thanks for your input.

Mawgan.
compositepro
compositepro
Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)Supreme Being (156 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 22, Visits: 65
Are you really only 23?
andygtt
andygtt
Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)Supreme Being (770 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 157, Visits: 1.2K
Notwithstanding the name of the forum, this is for discussion with the odd chip in from EC... They have a separate forum for technical support.

It's quite clear a lot of EC target market is the amateur rather than professional and to me it's one of their goals to remove the 'black art' claims that the carbon industry as a whole gives off.

I'm all for additional advice, but I'm going to be pretty vocal about people dissing EC advice and support because as a client of theirs that had absolutely zero knowledge before speaking to them I have now produced quite exceptional and hugelly complicated/ challenging parts that I couldn't have dreamed of without their support.

Now it's true I don't yet have the quality that a full professional may have, but also I don't have the facilities as I'm doing it in my garage and im making parts that are 2.5x2.5m that even the composite professionals refused to attempt (I did try)... Hence I sought out EC and they gave me the confidence to have a go myself.

I know I'm not alone in believing their advice and service to their target market is second to none!

We welcome your advice and expertise and I am especially looking forward to your advice in the resin infusion process as that's realistically the only way I can make the relativelly complex large parts I make :-)
Edited 11 Years Ago by andygtt
Shaneer22
Shaneer22
Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)Supreme Being (749 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 156, Visits: 14K
The best thing anyone can do is read about boat building and the techniques involved iam quite amazed at people that don't understand the basics regarding fillers general bonding etc. iam no engineer but to use carbon to its full potential weighing up all the variable's and calculations is way above my head,but there is something satisfying with the finished product,many years I attended a carbonology course to try to resolve problems I was having but at the end I learnt jack s***,the only way you learn is through your own mistakes getting yourself into a mess is part and parcell.
Warren (Staff)
Warren (Staff)
Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)Supreme Being (15K reputation)
Group: Administrators
Posts: 2.5K, Visits: 8K
nothing wrong with the OP's tips and they sure do have thier places in the higher levels of advanced composites.

Use of carbon and woven materials the process' used with them are by industry standards "advanced".

most the composites industry is still using pikey spec chopped strand mat wet laid with polyester.............. 

Spike rollers and breather tows are something we have never had the need to use at this level.  Im not sure there would be significant benefit in advising people to do it either. 

Same with "issues" around ramp rates and dwell times.

Sure on large production scales and in critical industries where you need the ultimate reliability, consistancy during manufacture etc it may well be a necessary process to ensure minor faults dont screw up a large expensive layup.  However that is not the case for most of our customers.

The pre-pregs we use and sell, we generally have never had issues with ramp rates needing to be too critical or dwell periods.  Perfectly good parts are being achieved daily both by us, and more importantly our customers with the techniques we advise currently.

Not saying we don't welcome further advice and ways to improve, we do and update things as and when.  But we also don't want to make things complicated when in practice its not necessary for most of the people using our products.

As said before, many techniques and processes have thier place, albeit with overlap. 

As an example, in our workshop once we had got some experience of the pre-pregs we use, we can just put them straight into our oven (which is on all the time) with no ramp up rates or similar.  The reason we "get away with it" is because a room temperature mould of any reasonable size will naturally have a reasonable temperature ramp up rate as it absorbs heat from the oven anyway.


Im sure some people will find your guide useful so we welcome extra information and advise, however what may work for you and seem the only "professional way" to do something isnt necessarily the case for others so would prefer people to be more open minded rather than saying "x is wrong, y is right, z is un-professional etc".  We try to keep it friendly here so more discussion the merrier!! We don't want to end up like some other composites forums where people get dissed and slated for not doing things one way or another.

Warren Penalver
Easy Composites / Carbon Mods - Technical Support Assistant
Edited 11 Years Ago by Warren (Staff)
morepower
morepower
Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)Supreme Being (1.1K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 242, Visits: 1.2K
I agree with much of what Warren has said... I have never put glass tows on the flange area under the pre-preg... I understand that moulds heat up slower than the oven too so the ramp could be lower or at the right rate as the material needs... But if the mould is not thick enough it can heat up too quickly. So I always try and make the oven (cardboard box, wheelie bin or actual oven) heat up slowly to give the material the best chance. 

Although I do think de-bulking after the first couple of layers are put down does give a better part and having a perfect bag and not rushing to lay it then cook it. Take your time with the whole process. Lay down the first couple of layers, de-bulk, next couple of layers or final layers and de-bulk overnight before cooking it... If you have more layers bag it and de-bulk for every 2 to 3 layers if you have a thicker part.. But always make sure the bag is good and leave the pump running... If you are getting "smoke" or vapour from the pump you have a leak and really need to find it... The better the bag the better the part.. When you cook the part dont let it heat up too fast too.... I would say dwell it at 65 degrees for an hour too... before heating it up any higher... Also always work to the temperature of the part NOT the oven... One of these works fine but if you get one test it with boiling water and ice to check it is accurate. If it is accurate tape it to the part and work from this... It will give you better parts even working from home.... But it is mostly down to technique and taking your time...

This part is not going to be seen so the mould was dull and is made using an out of autoclave carbon that is not supposed to give a good cosmetic finish.. But it worked perfectly with no pinholes at all... 


Here is a cosmetic Out of Autoclave parts finish in a polished mould and it works perfectly fine if you take your time and do try and control how it cooks and do not rush... (No it has not been lacquered either this is out of the mould) I do work from home too even though I do have access to a larger oven for my bodywork.. but the smaller first part was made at home and cooked in a cardboard box oven.....

GO

Merge Selected

Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Similar Topics

Reading This Topic

Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search