Which of these pumps would be best?


Author
Message
Otolithco
O
Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 13, Visits: 56
Gast DOA-P707-FB  listed at $200 obo

Gast 2067-v108 listed at $500 obo

These pumps are available locally and are new.

Anyone have experience with these pumps? Would they be suitable for composites? My parts are going to be in bag rather than a mold. Parts are roughly 5' long by 6" wide. 

Any help would be appreciated. 

Thanks
oekmont
oekmont
Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 550, Visits: 27K
In my opinion both pumps are not ideal for composite work. Just get a cheap rotary vane pump. They are much cheaper, better suited for composite processes and will last virtually forever, membranes will not.

Otolithco
O
Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 13, Visits: 56
oekmont - 6/28/2018 7:28:40 PM
In my opinion both pumps are not ideal for composite work. Just get a cheap rotary vane pump. They are much cheaper, better suited for composite processes and will last virtually forever, membranes will not.

The bigger Gast is a rotary vane I believe. Although I don't know much about pumps. Would this one just be overkill?


oekmont
oekmont
Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)Supreme Being (3.2K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 550, Visits: 27K
Sorry, it should be an oil bathed Rotary vane. The bigger one is oil free. Which means that the vacuum level is not good enough for resin infusion. For vacuum compression it should be ok, though.
so overkill, no, not by any means except maybe volume flow. But for 500$ you can allmost get an dvp ec 20, wich would be overkill, and which got even better volume flow. Or almost 5 cheap oil bathed vacuum pumps, wich will each suit your needs.

Otolithco
O
Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)Supreme Being (103 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 13, Visits: 56
oekmont - 6/29/2018 4:17:32 AM
Sorry, it should be an oil bathed Rotary vane. The bigger one is oil free. Which means that the vacuum level is not good enough for resin infusion. For vacuum compression it should be ok, though.
so overkill, no, not by any means except maybe volume flow. But for 500$ you can allmost get an dvp ec 20, wich would be overkill, and which got even better volume flow. Or almost 5 cheap oil bathed vacuum pumps, wich will each suit your needs.

Awesome thanks for the help!
Fasta
Fasta
Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)Supreme Being (2.5K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 468, Visits: 3.5K
I have used a smaller gast for a long time and it works fine, just a bit noisy compared to others.

Now I use a Rieschle but the Gast is still a working backup.




Edited 6 Years Ago by Fasta
drippy
drippy
Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)Supreme Being (207 reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 32, Visits: 388
I used a gast pump when I first started. I was only able to pull 20 from it and for small parts it worked ok but anything of size it was pretty worthless. I picked up a couple Robinair pumps and never looked back. Image result for robinair
Steve Broad
Steve Broad
Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)Supreme Being (2.1K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 408, Visits: 4.1K
I use EC's pump and it works fine. Pulled a good vacuum on my car's front clip (around 1.6m x 1.6m x 0.6m) so will cope with most things.
GO

Merge Selected

Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Similar Topics

Reading This Topic

Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search