Talk Composites - The Forum for Advanced Composites
Back
Login
Register
Login
Register
Home
»
Easy Composites Ltd Technical Support
»
Easy Composites Ltd - Product Specific Pages
»
Carbon Fibre Tube and Section
»
Carbon Fiber tube comparison to steel
Carbon Fiber tube comparison to steel
Post Reply
Like
5
Carbon Fiber tube comparison to steel
View
Flat Ascending
Flat Descending
Threaded
Options
Subscribe to topic
Print This Topic
Goto Topics Forum
Author
Message
hell.onwheels
hell.onwheels
posted 12 Years Ago
ANSWER
HOT
Topic Details
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4,
Visits: 37
Hi
I need to replace a steel tube 1500mm long (25mm OD - not sure yet what ID is) with one that is made from your roll wrapped tube range. The Tube is supported at either end and is loaded along its length. No Torsional forces are acting on the tube.
My question is: can I simply replace with a CF tube that is approximately 25mm OD? Will this new CF tube be over or under engineered.
Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated.
Russell
Reply
Like
5
Replies
wozza
wozza
posted 12 Years Ago
ANSWER
HOT
Post Details
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 688,
Visits: 5.4K
hell.onwheels (19/02/2013)
Hi
I need to replace a steel tube
ERW,CDS?
1500mm long (25mm OD - not sure yet what ID is) with one that is made from your roll wrapped tube range. The Tube is supported at either end
How is it supported
and is loaded along its length.
Do you mean under Compression ?
No Torsional forces are acting on the tube.
In real life not many applications don't involve bending moments.
My question is: can I simply replace with a CF tube that is approximately 25mm OD? Will this new CF tube be over or under engineered.
Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated.
Russell
More info please.
Carbon
Copies Ltd
Reply
Like
4
hell.onwheels
hell.onwheels
posted 12 Years Ago
ANSWER
HOT
Post Details
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4,
Visits: 37
Thanks for replying
I am trying to make a child's hammock/cot that is attached to the door pillars of a camper van. Basically 2 steel poles that hook on to some brackets that are fixed to the door posts - this attached picture hopefully shows what I mean. I do not know what type of steel was originally used as I have never actually seen one with my own eyes.
I was planning to have some inserts made up incorporating some sort of hook (maybe in aluminium or steel) that i will bond into the ends of the tube. I'm not sure how long the inserts need to be so that they will effectively spread the load from the end into the tube.
What do think?
Attachments
Hammock13.jpg
(
683 views,
56.00 KB
)
Reply
Like
4
GO
Merge Selected
Merge into selected topic...
Merge into merge target...
Merge into a specific topic ID...
Open Merge
Threaded View
Threaded View
Carbon Fiber tube comparison to steel
hell.onwheels
-
12 Years Ago
[quote][b]hell.onwheels (19/02/2013)[/b][hr]Hi I need to replace a steel tube ERW,CDS? 1500mm long...
wozza
-
12 Years Ago
Thanks for replying I am trying to make a child's hammock/cot that is attached to the door pillars...
hell.onwheels
-
12 Years Ago
Ok, now I see where you are going. I would imagine that the steel tube would be straight forward...
wozza
-
12 Years Ago
I agree with Warren. :laugh: The important thing here is spreading the load. In theory you could...
Warren (Staff)
-
12 Years Ago
Many thanks for the replies. I would like the least amount of bending to occur. If I went a size...
hell.onwheels
-
12 Years Ago
Without knowing exact weights and dimensions and measuring it, it would be impossible to work out...
Warren (Staff)
-
12 Years Ago
Russell, You also need to provide the OD, or the wall thickness. We can run a simple FE simulation...
singcomposite
-
11 Years Ago
to be fair, with the basic mechanical data and simple maths you can calculate the strength of a...
Warren (Staff)
-
11 Years Ago
Post Reply
Like
5
Similar Topics
Post Quoted Reply
Reading This Topic
Login
Login
Remember Me
Reset Password
Resend Validation Email
Login
Facebook
Google
Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search